Tag: Project Based Learning

  • Online Can’t Mimic Face-to-Face Learning

    The irony is that this video was created for a class project. Students will do incredible work if the task is engaging.

    You can’t just “upload” your class.

    As I scroll through teacher social media I keep seeing posts: “How do I have students take notes virtually? Does anyone have a good powerpoint on _________ that they can share? Who has a PDF of the textbook? How do you grade ___________(rote activity) online? What is your favorite app for tracking student engagement.” And the horrible behavior guidelines for Zoom that are not only controlling, but invasive of student privacy.

    Please don’t start your remote or hybrid learning thinking that you can mimic the face-to-face experience. This is especially true if you run a traditional, teacher-centered classroom. You can’t “upload” your face-to-face lessons to your school’s LMS and be done. Don’t plan on video or asynchronous lectures and slides with notes, expecting every student to watch them and excel. You can’t just scan worksheets to PDF and ask students to print at home.

    All of the social media requests from teachers basically asking for canned resources shows me that we have a long way to go pedagogically. Many teachers are not student-centered face-to-face and are trying to replicate the only thing that they know online.

    So here’s 6 things you shouldn’t expect from remote learning and what to do instead.

    Go as fast

    Everything is going to take longer than in school. Logging in, introducing the technology, teaching, building relationships, and even attendance. But think about how many things are better done slowly: crockpots, BBQ, and walks outside.

    No sense stressing, accept the slower pace. One quarantine lesson is that it is more human to take our time and focus on the significant people in our lives. It’s not healthy living every moment at a frantic pace. Plan extra time for everything and center on your students, not completing tasks.

    Cover the same amount of standards/content

    First of all, let’s just delete the word “cover” from education. Curriculum is bloated with too much content already. Since we are moving slower, then we need to focus on less material. Winnow your class down to the essential standards that are fundamental to the discipline or will be needed as prerequisites in following classes. Instead of a shallow drive through a zillion topics, go deep on a few and concentrate on developing the skills, not just memorizing facts.

    Run a normal bell schedule

    I can’t believe how many districts are trying to do this. They think that kids are going to engage sitting in online meetings for 30 hours a week? This is ludicrous and the school leaders are out of their minds. It is not going to work for any amount of time. Online meetings are exhausting for adults and students alike. I think 2-3 hours a day is maximum for secondary students.

    Instead assign students projects and hands on activities to do throughout the day such as science investigations outside, choice reading, and PBL. Kids don’t need to be “on camera” to be learning. Teachers should have regular office hours to consult and help students as needed, but requiring students to sit through their daily schedule online is asinine.

    Take attendance by simulating butts in seats

    Similar to above, we can’t take normal procedures like attendance and shift wholesale to online. I even heard one teacher say that their district is asking parents to keep track that their child is online and verify it. If you post videos that for asynchronous viewing and your student views it at 1am, were they absent? If older students provide childcare for siblings and “attend” your class in the evening were they absent?

    Let’s find creative ways to check in with kids and relax outdated policies. Let’s assign credit based on the actual proof of learning of the content of the course, rather than whether or not they were physically present in front of a camera at any given time.

    Micromanage student behavior

    Don’t make a bunch of rules to regulate students–you can’t control participation, distractions, what kids are wearing, where they are, or if their eyes are on the screen the whole time. Quit trying to control students! Who cares if they are in PJs or eating breakfast. At least if they spill, you won’t have to clean it up! I saw one system set up for points if students were on time to the Zoom call, stayed the whole time, and had their eyes on the screen 95% of the time. I am not sure how you even measure that!

    Instead of worrying about student behavior, build community. Many students have experienced trauma through the double tragedies of Covid and the murder of George Floyd. Remote learning adds another layer of stress for them and places our most disadvantaged learners at an even greater risk. Get to know your students deeply. Foster SEL Competencies. Let your class overflow with love, grace, and caring.

    Be boring

    Those powerpoints and videos of you lecturing aren’t going to cut it. Kids are going to tune you out and play a game on their phone. Kids will find ways to copy your worksheet answers and shortcut your lectures. They will cheat on assessments and basically learn hardly anything at all.

    Instead challenge kids with a project that involves movement and hands on activities. Create Project Based Learning lessons around themes in your content. Give kids design challenges to motivate them.

    The final products could be digital or a picture or video (Flipgrid is an excellent tool) of a physical product. Worried about supplies? Have students upcycle from their junk drawers and recycling bins. Prototypes can be made from just about anything. Even while social distancing students can still connect with community experts and family members through video calls.

    Conclusion

    Of course, I have been arguing for years, that these kind of practices should end in face-to-face classes too. But it is obvious that they are still the dominant pattern in many classrooms. The difference with online classes is that cheating is easier and teachers really can’t control students when they check out. A subset of kids who care about grades and achievement (or their parents do) will do whatever is asked of them, but many kids are going to quit playing the game of school.

    We can do better. Kids deserve better! Let’s find ways to make online learning as personable and engaging as possible!

    Let’s Connect

    Questions? Interested in SEL and PBL workshops or consulting on remote learning?  Connect with me at  michaelkaechele.com or @mikekaechele.

  • Planning PBL is like Robbing a Bank

    One of the most common misconceptions about Project Based Learning is that student voice and choice turns the classroom into a free-for-all. People envision students pursuing random passions at will. When an educator voices this fear, they assume that the teacher is not doing much. They wonder how PBL teachers guarantee that the content standards are met?

    They presume that the PBL teacher doesn’t actually plan much at all. In reality, these assumptions couldn’t be further from the truth.

    When I think about designing a PBL project, I am reminded of the Spanish Netflix show, Money Heist. In the same genre as the Ocean’s Eleven heist movies, the TV drama features a team of misfit criminals robbing the royal mint of Spain. Instead of being villains, the robbers are portrayed as Robin Hoods against the capitalist system.

    All of the thieves take on city names as aliases to protect their true identities in case anyone is captured. Key members are Berlin, Tokyo, Denver, Rio, Helsinki, and Nairobi. Everyone is nicknamed after a city except for the master planner, the Professor.

    The Professor is a control freak who has been designing the heist for years and meticulously considered every detail. He has blueprints and a model of the mint. He knows the key officials and their routines. He has chosen his team with great care based on their personalities and skillsets. He knows the practices of the police and special forces. He anticipates every move. He has contingency plans for when things go wrong and back up plans to his back up plans. He quite literally has thought of everything.

    During the heist, the Professor is on the outside monitoring the police and media reactions. He communicates to the team, working on the inside of the mint. As things go wrong, the Professor calls multiple audibles from his plethora of backup plans. As you might guess, eventually something surprises the team that even the Professor in all of his meticulous planning did not anticipate.

    Berlin and Tokyo, two of the leaders on the inside, lose communication with the Professor and are on their own. They know the plans but also have their own thoughts and desires. Tokyo pivots and reacts to surprise circumstances. The Professor’s plans are great, but improvisation is required. In the end, all that matters is that they accomplish two goals: steal the money and get the team out alive.

    Planning PBL projects is like planning a bank robbery. The teacher sets up a problem for students to engage and solve. She painstakingly considers every angle and plans protocols and routines for students to be successful. But just like the Professor, she is on the “outside” of the actual project work. Students have to complete the project themselves. Oftentimes they have different ways of thinking, processing, and moving forward than the teacher. And that’s OK. The teacher has to be willing to step back from the plans, even though they took so much work to create, and follow students as they create their own paths toward success.

    So PBL teachers, plan like you are as OCD as the Professor, but pivot like Tokyo when students choose a different path to the same goal.

    As long as content standards are learned, discipline skills are mastered, and SEL competencies are developed it doesn’t matter if you have to scrap your entire master plan. Be prepared to Flex like Stretch Armstrong.

    Planning PBL is easier if you have relationships with students. The better that you know your kids, the better your plans will be, customized to their strengths, passions, and quirks.

    When you are really good you will anticipate how students will pivot from your plans and prepare options.

    When you are really, really good, you will plan opportunities for students to blow your plans out of the water and take the project to places you’ve never dreamed of.

    Remember:

    • Relationships trump plans.
    • Culture trumps plans.
    • Kids trump plans.
    • Curiosity trumps plans.

    Yet you still need to plan like their lives depend on it. Plan like the Professor; Pivot like Tokyo.

    Questions? Interested in SEL and PBL Consulting?  Connect with me at michaelkaechele.com or @mikekaechele onTwitter.