Category: Uncategorized

  • Content or Skills, What’s More Important?

    I saw a Facebook post this week where a teacher was asked in an interview, “What’s more important, teaching content or skills?” The extensive thread of comments were fascinating with people taking all kinds of positions from choosing one side, calling it a stupid question, or pointing out that it’s not an either/or question. While I can agree that it seems like some kind of gotcha question for an interview, I do have a strong opinion on this one (No surprise there!).

    I will always argue for skills over content, specifically Social and Emotional Learning skills. But let’s start by only considering core content skills vs. content. The standards that have been ordained from on high for us to teach in schools represent such a minute fraction of the knowledge of the world. New human understanding grows exponentially every second. Textbooks need to be updated due to errors and better understandings of the world. Something as crucial as how the human brain works was barely understood 30 years ago. Therefore I would argue that the most important standards are the ones focused on skills such as problem-solving, reading and writing fluency, critical analysis, and scientific reasoning.

    In making the argument for skills over content, I am not saying that content does not matter at all. Of course it does, but it is less vital.

    • A student with strong observation and reasoning skills can study the background of a science topic and design an experiment to test a hypothesis. Better yet, they know what to do with unexpected results and how to iterate to develop a theory.
    • When a student has number sense and mathematical reasoning, they can solve new problems without having to be taught algorithms first.
    • A student who knows how to interpret analogies, metaphors, and similes can apply their skills to poetry from an author that they have never read previously.
    • When a student knows how to evaluate primary sources for point of view and author intention, they can apply historical thinking to present day current events.

    These core content skills are transferrable to any career or learning path.

    SEL competencies may seem even more removed from content, but I would argue that they are the most important skills of all. Long after students forget the content of the class, we still want them to be quality humans. Our dream for students is that they would be Self and Socially Aware, recognizing strengths in themselves and in the diversity of the world around them. We want to develop students who build strong relationships with colleagues, family, and friends. The world needs future leaders who can resolve differences through respectful negotiation, not senseless violence. Complex issues such as climate change, global inequity, and socio-political power struggles require Responsible Decision-Makers who consider multiple perspective and move in directions to benefit all of humanity, not just wealthy nations.

    A “side effect” of students cultivating SEL skills is academic growth (and here) in the content areas.

    • Perseverance and growth mindset in Self-Awareness teach students to work through academic difficulties.
    • The organizational skills of Self-Management lead to quality work completed on time.
    • Social Awareness helps students analyze situations from multiple perspectives.
    • Communication and collaboration of Relationship Skills enables students to exchange complex ideas in written and verbal forms.
    • The problem solving of Responsible Decision-Making leads to deep understanding of academic content and its application to real world problems.

    SEL competencies are intricately intertwined with academic skills and are at the heart of deeper learning.

    Returning to the original situation, is this a legitimate interview question? Again, I would argue yes. My assumption, unless shown otherwise through stories and examples told, is that the teacher who thinks content is king tends to be less progressive. They probably use lecture as their primary tool to “deliver” content to their class and may be skeptical of PBL. So the explanation that a prospective teacher gives for their choice, not necessarily the choice itself, should reveal useful details about their pedagogy and style of teaching to determine whether they are a good fit with the school beliefs and culture.

    What say you? Content or skills? Which one do you value more?

    Interested in learning how you can develop SEL skills integrated in your classroom? Check out my virtual workshops this summer! I am also booking workshops with schools across the country on PBL and SEL.

  • Unforgettable Endings to the Year

    Most schools are reaching the end of the year and have completed standardized testing. I see many teacher requests for movies to show in my Facebook feed. What if we ended the year with an open-ended project instead? It might be a culmination of your content themes for the year or it might just be tied to something authentic in the community. When students start getting antsy for summer, projects can motivate and finish the year strong. It’s a great time for students to demonstrate the SEL competencies that they have been developing all year. Here’s four examples from my classroom.

    World Simulation

    At the conclusion of a freshman World History integrated with English class, we created a fictional world, putting students in different teams to tackle global issues. It was inspired by John Hunter’s Ted Talk (one of my all time favorites). The Driving Question was “How would you rule the world?” Each team was given a land mass to create their own country and laws. They had different natural resources and economic opportunities. Students loved it, and were able to apply the concepts of fairness, environmental stewardship, negotiation, and problem-solving.

    Hobby Day

    At my PBL high school, we had a hobby day the last week of the year. All of the teachers would bring in tools and materials and lead a session on something that they are passionate about. Students could then choose which ones they were interested in. Options included things such as making root beer, jewelry, woodturning, scrapbooking, and outdoor hikes in the woods.

    I, of course, had students mix and form concrete to make tea light candleholders. It was so much fun making things with students and letting them into another side of who, we the teachers are.

    River City Redesign

    The Water Project was undoubtedly, my favorite project ever! We integrated all sophomore classes into one massive project to end the year. The focus was to redesign the riverfront in downtown Grand Rapids based on the proposed plan to return the river to its natural state by removing and lowering dams. The Driving Question was “How can we as architects redesign the Grand River waterfront to promote ecological and economic growth for our city?” Students applied chemistry as they studied water quality, geometry in creating a 3D scaled plan, and social studies as they surveyed the community and plotted the best ideas for environmental sustainability and economic growth. We studied how rivers have been revitalized all over the country and world.

    During this project, students flexed their SEL skills. Leaders choose themselves and came up with new ideas and plans for the project. A marketing team was created by students excelling at public communications sharing the project with the community. Collaboration between teams was a challenge that students met by calling meetings and working out compromises and timelines. Students organized a compelling final showcase and successfully invited many community leaders. They problem-solved both the project and the problem at hand-making the city proud of its river-with creativity and passion.

    Legacy Project

    Our school was a somewhat worn modular building that did not necessarily make students feel valued or important. We challenged all of our students to come up with a plan to improve our facilities. We asked them, “What will be my legacy at East Lee Campus?” Students brainstormed many ideas both inside and out. We found support from a local painter who donated labor, equipment, and some paint. A local bank who matched those funds and students were able to paint the outside of our building, remove a chainlink fence that made them feel like prisoners, and update the landscaping.

    Before and After

    The tests are over. The pressure is off, and the possibilities are endless. How could you end the school year with meaningful work that students will remember for the rest of their lives? What opportunities disguised as problems are in your community? How can your students flex their SEL strengths to make a difference?

    Interested in learning how you can develop SEL skills integrated in your classroom? Check out my virtual workshops this summer! I am also booking workshops with schools across the country on PBL and SEL.