Category: Uncategorized

  • #Stopcommoncore and me

    I am having some cognitive dissonance when I watch Glen Beck

    If you don’t want to watch it all Glen Beck has three problems with the Common Core

    1. Poor curriculum
    2. Loss of states’ rights
    3. Data mining

    By the way the video is full of misrepresentations and I am not going to try and point them all out. I think he definitely misrepresents the curriculum of the CC and how it is “forced on homeschoolers.” I also have no problem with the alternate math methods he shows. But while I disagree with many of his points and feel that he is not pointing an accurate picture of the CC, I find myself equally against the CC but for these three reasons.

    1. Narrow curriculum
    2. Loss of district/school/community/students’ rights
    3. Conflict of interests of the powers behind it.

    What I don’t like about any national curriculum is that it takes away the choice from teachers and students to study what they choose to study. I find it to be too sterile and prescriptive for what individual students need in their lives. I believe it is arrogant for anyone to determine here is what “every student needs to learn to be successful.” So really my first two items are the same complaint that education should be negotiated locally between the community and schools including room for individual student passions.

    Strange Bedfellows http://blogs.r.ftdata.co.uk/beyond-brics/files/2012/06/bedfellows.jpg
    Strange Bedfellows http://blogs.r.ftdata.co.uk/beyond-brics/files/2012/06/bedfellows.jpg

    I know that the CC is not the same as standardized testing, but since the testing will be driven by the CC and all school funding based off from agreeing to this I believe that it is impossible to separate the two. Funding is the real power that the federal government is using to manipulate states into agreeing to CC and the testing that goes with it. The fact that there are testing companies all mixed up in this is a major problem for me. I actually agree with Glenn Beck about the involvement of the Gates Foundation and the danger of data mining.

    So while I don’t agree with the rhetoric of the #stopcommoncore movement on how terrible the CC curriculum is (I don’t think it is perfect either), I do find myself agreeing with them that I think CC is a continued part of the federal government standardizing schools and hindering passionate, personalized learning. So does that make us allies?

    PS: For more detailed deconstruction of problems of the CC check out Paul Bogush’s blog.

  • Stories

    Lifted from http://www.danbirlew.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/03/ender1.jpg
    Lifted from http://www.danbirlew.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/03/ender1.jpg

    An edited conversation between the Queen Hive of the Buggers and the Fathertrees of the piggies about how humans are different from them in Xenocide, the third book in the Ender’s Game series.

    “They’re so hungry for answers, these humans. They have so many questions….They want to know why, why, why. Or how. …”(Queen Hive)

    “They like to understand everything. But so do we, you know.” (Fathertrees)

    “Yes, you’d like to think you’re just like the humans, wouldn’t you? But you’re not like Ender. Not like the humans. He has to know the cause of everything, he has to make a story about everything and we don’t know any stories. We know memories…We don’t even care why, the way these humans do. We find out as much as we need to know to accomplish something, but they always want to know more than they need to know. After they get something to work, they’re still hungry to know why it works and why the cause of its working works.” (Queen Hive)

    …”We know about their dreaming.” (Fathertrees)

    “They’re practicing. They’re doing it all the time. Coming up with stories. Making connections. Making sense out of nonsense.” (Queen Hive)

    “What good is it, when it means nothing.” (Fathertrees)

    “That’s just it. They have a hunger we know nothing about. The hunger for answers. The hunger for making sense. The hunger for stories.” (Queen Hive)

    “We have stories.” (Fathertrees)

    “You remember deeds. They make up deeds. They change what their stories mean. They transform things so that the same memory can mean a thousand different things. Even from their dreams, sometimes they make up out of that randomness something that illuminates everything. Not one human being has anything like the kind of mind you have. The kind we have. Nothing as powerful. And their lives are so short, they die so fast. but in their century or so they come up with ten thousand meanings for every one that we discover…

    But in Ender’s mind, madness. Thousands of competing contradictory impossible visions that make no sense at all because they can’t all fit together but they do fit together, he makes them fit together, this way today, that way tomorrow, as they’re needed. As if he can make a new idea-machine inside his head for every new problem he faces. As if he conceives of a new universe to live in, every hour a new one, often hopelessly wrong and he ends up making mistakes and bad judgments, but sometimes so perfectly right that it opens things up like a miracle and I look through his eyes and see the world his new way and it changes everything. Madness and then illumination  We knew everything there was to know before we met these humans, before we built our connection with Ender’s mind. Now we discover that there are so many ways of knowing the same things that we’ll never find them all.” (Queen Hive)

    I think this is a pretty good explanation of what it means to be human. In these lines I see learning through trial and error, curiosity, questioning, exploring, longing for purpose and meaning, and the importance of stories.

    Are stories a part of your students’ lives? Your classroom? Does your class resemble this at all?